The Church Should Be Political (But not Partisan)
Pope Leo, calling for peace in the Middle East, condemned the “absurd and inhuman violence” that has led to the “unimaginable loss of life” in that region. It is noteworthy that he did not call for victory for one side or the other, but for peace. President Trump responded to these remarks by admonishing the pontiff to “focus on being a great Pope, not a politician.”
Trump’s appeal to the separation of religion and politics is not uncommon. Many church leaders also separate religion and politics, claiming that their churches are “not political” but instead “focus on the gospel.” As a pastor with decades of experience, I believe this seemingly neutral stance is more about avoiding offense and less about faithfulness to a theological conviction.
This Gospel is Political
“Politics” involve the distribution of both power and resources among a group of people. During the era of Caesar’s reign, Jesus triumphantly entered a city claimed by Rome. As he was lauded as King by the people, he accepted that adoration and announced the arrival of the Kingdom of God. It’s hard to imagine a more politically charged message, and it did not go without notice or consequences. Then to the gathered crowds, Jesus preached the values of the Kingdom of God, raising issues such as feeding the poor, caring for the sick, welcoming strangers (foreigners), and visiting prisoners. He affirmed everyone’s dignity and warned that nations would be judged by how they resource the most vulnerable. Two-thousand years later, our political discourse continues to revolve around these same issues. It therefore seems difficult to deny that the gospel is deeply political, carrying with it the looming judgment of God for those who do not embrace the values of the Kingdom of God.
But it is not Partisan
Although the Gospel is political, it is not partisan. Partisanship answers a gospel concern by saying, “therefore vote for my guy.” When we claim that a certain candidate or party is the means to bring about the Kingdom of God on earth, we cross the line into partisanship. Churches in America are deeply divided across party lines, many claiming “You can’t be a Christian and vote for (insert a political party or candidate here).” I do believe churches should enter the political arena to resist destructive powers and advocate for the most vulnerable among us. We should apply the gospel to political issues. We should not, however, conclude that a single political party or candidate is the answer.
Partisanship Falls Short
Partisanship leads to simplistic solutions without nuance. Let’s take the abortion issue for example. The typical Evangelical response is partisan, aligning with the right, simply seeking to criminalize the procedure. This approach, while genuinely intended to protect the unborn, lacks nuance. This is because it often ignores, or works against, addressing the complex set of circumstances that contribute to higher abortion rates. These include poverty, housing and food insecurity, student debt, access to medical care, family leave and childcare, and sex education. Furthermore, criminalization has resulted in denial of healthcare for women with dangerous pregnancies. Partisanship, therefore, works against applying a wholistic and nuanced response to the issue.
Partisanship leads to Christian Nationalism. Partisanship quickly makes the leap from “my candidate” to “God’s candidate.” Christian nationalism believes that a certain country is God’s favored nation to bring about God’s purposes on earth. When we look to human government as the solution, and leverage the state to bring about the kingdom of God, we commit idolatry by elevating something or someone to the place where only God belongs.
Partisanship results in misplaced priorities. Partisanship leverages power and resources to benefit oneself and one’s own people. Love, however, means that we work together to bring about collective wellbeing.[1] The scope of a Christian’s love should prioritize all of creation, both people and places. The gospel culminates in the redemption of every nation, tribe, people and language (Rev. 7:9). A policy, therefore, that benefits oneself or one’s own, while denying, disadvantaging, or damaging another person or place, does not take the gospel seriously.
Partisanship leads to false dichotomy. American political discourse seems to divide the good guys and bad guys. So, let’s remember that both parties fund opportunistic wars and take money from special interests in exchange for favor. Human government will always fail us, regardless of political party. Remember, when we choose “the lesser of two evils,” we are simultaneously admitting that both are evil.
Partisanship leads to division. Often, opposing positions have common interests. For example, elevating the poor is a common interest among many on both the left and right. However, they advocate for different positions, or methods, to accomplish that interest. Some take the position of higher taxes on the rich, some lower. Then, rather than uniting over the common interest of compassion for the disadvantaged, we divide over the positions of one’s party. Focusing on partisan positions rather than common interests[2] leads to unproductive arguments and destructive division among God’s people.
In conclusion, I call on my fellow clergy to join Pope Leo and courageously speak out whenever the distribution of power and resources in our nation do not reflect the priorities and values of the Kingdom of God. The King will reply, “Truly I tell you, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me (Matt 25:40 NIV).
[1] Thanks to Thomas Jay Oord for this definition.
[2] Thanks to Ken Sande for this distinction.